A man with paranoid schizophrenia who killed three elderly men in Exeter was released from police custody twice in the 48 hours before the murders, following a “catalogue of failures” by officers and medical staff, according to a joint investigation by the Sunday Times and BBC Radio 4.
Alexander Lewis-Ranwell, 27, attacked Anthony Payne, 80, and twin brothers Roger and Dick Carter, 84, in their homes in 2019. The victims were bludgeoned with a hammer and a spade during a rampage that lasted several hours.
Police ignored critical warnings
Video footage from police body cameras shows Lewis-Ranwell exhibiting severe distress while in custody. He was seen semi-naked, hissing, spitting, and punching at the hatch window of his cell. He also ranted about paedophiles and claimed to see animals.
Despite this disturbing behaviour, officers released him twice. The first arrest occurred after he broke into a farm. The second arrest followed an incident where he attacked a farmer with a 1.2-metre logging saw.
Investigators found that police ignored warnings from a national database and a mental health assessor. A doctor sent to examine Lewis-Ranwell lacked specific expertise in mental health and dismissed his unpredictable actions. Officers also failed to record key details that would have highlighted the severity of his condition.
Crucially, police were unaware they had the legal power to detain him under the Mental Health Act without a medical assessment. Warnings from Lewis-Ranwell’s mother, who stated he was experiencing a psychotic episode and needed to be held in custody, were also disregarded.
Families seek accountability
The families of the three victims have called on the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) to open an investigation into Devon and Cornwall Police. They have waited two years for answers and an apology, with no response received so far.
Amanda Taylor, whose uncles Roger and Dick Carter were killed, told the Sunday Times she wants the IOPC to revisit the case. She stated that she wants one of the agencies involved to acknowledge the serious mistakes and the devastating consequences.
“All I want is for just one of the agencies involved to stand up and say: ‘We are so sorry. Serious mistakes were made,'” Taylor said.
Lewis-Ranwell was found not guilty by reason of insanity at Exeter Crown Court in December 2019. He was given a hospital restriction order and remains in a secure facility until agencies are confident he can be safely released.
A psychiatrist who studied the case described Lewis-Ranwell as “one of the illest people” he had encountered. A recent inquest confirmed that failings by police led to his release after a doctor missed clear signs of delusion and disordered thinking.
Systemic issues in mental health care
The case highlights broader concerns about community mental health care in the UK. A review by the Care Quality Commission into the 2023 Nottingham attacks by Valdo Calocane, who also had paranoid schizophrenia, concluded that a series of errors led to his discharge despite aggressive behaviour and medication non-compliance.
The report identified systemic issues that pose inherent risks to public safety. NHS England has since strengthened guidance for community mental health support for high-risk patients.
Julian Hendy of the victims’ charity Hundred Families noted that there are an estimated 100 to 120 mental health-related killings in the UK annually. He argued that if lessons from the Lewis-Ranwell case had been learned earlier, the Nottingham attacks might have been prevented.
A police spokesperson said the force was addressing areas of learning and would reflect on the inquest jury’s recommendations. The IOPC stated that the families have the right to ask for a review of the internal investigation but have not yet submitted a request.
Source: The Guardian

