Google has declined a request from the UK government to remove a YouTube video posted by the wife of jailed comedian Russell Brand, according to Whitehall sources. The Prison Service of England and Wales submitted the formal request, arguing the content was distressing to victims of Brand’s crimes.
Brand is currently serving a 10-and-a-half-year prison sentence for rape and three counts of sexual assault. The video in question was shared on Sunday by his wife, Laura Brand, on their channel. It featured a message read aloud in which Brand stated he was not guilty of the offences for which he was convicted.
Government and Platform Dispute
A spokesperson for the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) stated it was “only right” to ask for the removal of material that caused distress to victims. The department emphasized that while removal ultimately depends on the platform’s terms, YouTube should remove the content.
The request was made through an established mechanism between the Prison Service and tech companies, rather than through a direct ministerial meeting with Google executives, as initially reported. The Prison Service believed the video had reached a substantial audience and was offensive to Brand’s victims.
Google responded to the BBC by confirming its teams were investigating the new content. The company noted that it had suspended Russell Brand’s channel from the YouTube Partner Program in September 2023. Since that date, the channel has been unable to monetize content on the platform.
Despite the government’s stance, Google determined that the video did not break its community guidelines. The video and the Brands’ YouTube account remain active on the site.
Political and Public Reaction
The refusal has sparked debate among UK politicians and safeguarding advocates. Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook described the video as “abhorrent” and confirmed the government remained in close dialogue with Google. Meanwhile, former minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, Jess Phillips, highlighted the limitations of current regulatory powers.
Phillips told BBC Radio 4 that the government does not have the power to enforce the removal of the video. She suggested this incident highlights gaps in the Online Safety Act and indicated a likelihood of a second online safety act to address the unique challenges posed by prisoners with large digital followings.
Downing Street previously labeled the message “clearly appalling,” noting that prisoners are strictly banned from making statements that cause distress to victims. Education Secretary Lucy Powell also criticized media outlets for amplifying the message, describing Brand as showing no remorse or sensitivity to his victims.
Mia Latter, a woman who has made allegations against Brand, expressed that she found the message upsetting. She noted the contradiction of hearing a Christian message alongside what she described as lies. Brand has positioned himself as a Christian influencer in recent years and maintains a significant following.
While the YouTube content remains available, Brand’s social media accounts on Meta platforms, including Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp, were disabled last week. The Met Police are also investigating additional potential criminal allegations against him.
Source: BBC

