The Royal College of Nursing (RCN) has stated it is extremely dissatisfied with proposed legislation designed to strengthen safe staffing across health and social care services in Northern Ireland. The union argues that the current draft fails to adequately reflect the co-design processes it has been engaged in with the Department of Health since 2020.
Health Minister Robbie Butler introduced the Health and Social Care (Staffing) bill to the Stormont assembly on Monday. Butler described the move as a significant step forward in strengthening workforce planning and staffing governance. He stated that the legislation places safe and effective staffing at the heart of strategic decision-making and creates a clear legislative framework to support both care providers and patients.
RCN Criticizes Lack of Accountability
In a letter to the department seen by BBC News NI, RCN director Rita Devlin spelled out the union’s specific concerns. Devlin criticized the draft bill for seeming to imagine that responsibility for workforce planning could be delegated to individual health trusts. She insisted that all accountability and responsibility for workforce planning must reside solely within the Department of Health.
Devlin also highlighted the absence of guiding principles around workforce planning as a glaring omission. She argued that without these principles, the rest of the legislation is totally open to interpretation. The union believes that workforce planning is merely a means to an end, which is the delivery of safe and effective health and social care, rather than an end in itself.
Another point of contention is the title of the bill itself. Devlin noted that safe staffing does not appear in the title or indeed in the bill itself, a fact she described as causing great concern and disappointment to the union.

Political Opposition and Future Amendments
The proposed changes come amid continuing pressures on health and social care services in Northern Ireland. Growing demand and workforce challenges are affecting patient needs, creating a difficult environment for service delivery. While Scotland and Wales already have laws placing legal duties on NHS trusts to calculate and maintain safe staffing levels, the Stormont bill aims to strengthen how the health service plans its workforce and identifies staffing risks.
Political opposition to the bill has also emerged. Nuala McAllister, an Alliance Party member on Stormont’s health committee, accused Ulster Unionist health ministers of wasting six years producing a bill that will make little to no difference to safe staffing levels in hospital wards. She criticized the rejection of evidence-based proposals from frontline health leaders in favor of vague commitments.
McAllister stated that the Alliance Party would work with health unions to bring forward amendments to the bill. The goal is to ensure the legislation delivers the protections that staff have been calling for over the years. Devlin concluded that in the absence of the detail the RCN had hoped for, the union was in the regrettable position of having to lobby for amendments to the bill.
Source: BBC

