San Diego city council members voted on Monday evening to terminate contracts with two surveillance technology vendors, Flock and Ubicquia. The decision removes more than 500 cameras from the city just three years after Mayor Todd Gloria urged the council to approve the program.
San Diego is now one of the largest municipalities to end its relationship with Flock, a startup valued at approximately $8.3 billion. The vote also halts the operation of Ubicquia’s smart streetlights, which were installed to work in tandem with Flock’s automatic license plate reader software.
Political Shift and Council Debate
The reversal marks a significant change in local policy. Three years ago, city leaders pushed for the installation of these devices. Now, the council has moved to dismantle the system after intense public debate.

Council member Stephen Whitburn, who recently revoked his support for the program, stated that the cameras had lost their effectiveness as a public safety tool. He argued that if the technology made many residents feel unsafe, it failed its primary purpose. His shift in position created the necessary majority to pass the termination vote.
Mayor Gloria responded to the decision on social media, stating that he respected the council’s choice and would not attempt to veto the measure. The mayor had previously championed the surveillance network as a means to combat crime.
Industry and Advocacy Reactions
Andrew Smith, a spokesperson for Flock, expressed disappointment in an email to Ars Technica. He warned that removing a tool that actively helps solve violent crimes would move public safety backward. Smith listed specific consequences, including longer case resolution times, increased organized retail theft, and delays in returning missing children to their families.

Police representatives cited different data during the council meeting. They reported a 20 percent decline in vehicle theft since 2023, noting that the Flock cameras helped recover 689 stolen vehicles.
Advocacy groups celebrated the outcome. Lilly Irani of the Transparent and Responsible Use of Surveillance Technology Coalition said she felt victorious. She attributed the win to broad coalitions across the political spectrum that pressured the council. Irani noted that it was only last month that Whitburn changed his stance, allowing opponents to secure a majority.
Pegah Parsi, a member of the City of San Diego Privacy Advisory Board, said she felt vindicated. The board had previously asked the council to reject the plan. Parsi advised other institutions to listen to expert advisory boards, calling it cheaper than learning lessons the hard way.

A History of Rejected Surveillance Tech
This is not the first time San Diego has abandoned smart streetlight technology. The city previously purchased thousands of systems from GE Current, but a prior administration shut them down in 2020. Ubicquia later acquired the platform and proposed the current installation in 2023.
Brian Hofer, executive director of the Oakland-based group Secure Justice, highlighted a national trend. He stated that his organization had documented at least 513 Flock contracts ending across the United States. Hofer argued that the widespread cancellations show Americans do not consent to government tracking during their daily lives.
Source: Ars Technica

