A consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has formally requested a corporate homicide investigation into claims that patients at NHS Grampian died from preventable surgical errors over many years. Dr Mohammed Habib stated he is risking his career to expose what he describes as systemic negligence and a lack of accountability within the health board.
Dr Habib, who has served as a consultant with NHS Grampian since 2014, held a press conference on Thursday alongside his legal representative, Aamer Anwar. Anwar, a human rights campaigner, described the operating theatre environment as a “slaughterhouse” driven by incompetence. He emphasized that Dr Habib took this public step because his primary duty as a doctor is to protect patients, a principle he felt was being ignored by institutional leadership.
Leaked Reports Reveal High Mortality Rates
The whistleblower provided details from an unpublished expert review conducted in 2022. The report examined 45 patients who underwent liver and pancreatic surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary between 2015 and 2021. It found that 31 of these patients died, with 19 of those deaths classified as avoidable consequences of surgical intervention. This represents a 42 percent avoidable mortality rate within the studied cohort.

The review highlighted that mortality rates for major liver resections were significantly higher than national averages. Between 2017 and 2020, the death rate was 12 percent within 30 days and 18 percent within 90 days, compared to an expected rate of 2.2 percent. Experts criticized the decision-making process, noting that surgeries were sometimes pursued aggressively even when diseases were deemed inoperable. In pancreatic cases, patients were frequently rushed into surgery without adequate planning or consideration of non-surgical alternatives.
A second report released earlier this year reinforced these findings. It described the problems as long-standing and recurrent, noting that the unit lacked sufficient specialist staff to deliver services safely. The report strongly recommended that no complex hepatopancreatobiliary (HPB) surgery should take place at the Aberdeen facility.

Police and Health Board Responses
Dr Habib stated that he first became aware of avoidable surgery-related deaths in 2016. He formally raised serious concerns about dozens of potential fatalities in July 2021. In 2024, he submitted 20 specific cases from the previous decade to Police Scotland. Detective Superintendent Carron McKellar confirmed that enquiries are ongoing and a situational report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.
The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service stated that the concerns are being taken seriously, though the complexity of the issues means investigations remain active. NHS Grampian board chair Laura Skaife-Knight responded to the allegations by stating that a thorough investigation had already taken place. She added that any new evidence would be carefully considered through appropriate clinical and legal processes.
Dr Habib expressed frustration that previous attempts to use whistleblowing procedures failed to produce action. He noted that the Independent Whistleblowing Officer refused to progress his complaints and that the Scottish government claimed it had no jurisdiction to investigate the claims directly. He characterized the health board’s attitude as one of “wicked recklessness and an indifference to patient deaths.”

The Scottish government acknowledged the courage shown by the whistleblower. A spokesperson reiterated that a significant level of intervention and support is currently being provided to NHS Grampian to address leadership and cultural issues identified in recent reports.
Source: BBC

