A technical defect within the UK Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) is causing the department to knowingly overpay local housing allowance to certain claimants. The error has sparked serious concerns that the mistake could negatively impact the immigration status of partners who are not legally entitled to receive public funds.
System Defect Prevents Correct Calculation
The issue centers on a “recognised system defect” that prevents the DWP from automatically recalculating housing benefits for specific cases. Under current rules, individuals under the age of 35 are generally entitled to the shared accommodation rate. However, the glitch is causing the system to apply the higher one-bedroom rate for couples to these claimants.
In one documented case, a claimant has been receiving £790 per month instead of the correct £586. This discrepancy has resulted in an overpayment of more than £3,600 over the past 18 months. The DWP has confirmed that staff are instructed not to manually correct these accounts while the technical issue remains unresolved.
The situation is particularly complex for claimants whose partners are international students or others subject to immigration control. These individuals are typically barred from accessing public funds. When the Home Office was asked if the error could compromise the leave to remain of such partners, it referred the matter back to the DWP.
Tribunal Rulings and Operational Guidance
The claimant in the primary case attempted to resolve the issue through legal channels. A tribunal last year initially ruled that the living arrangements entitled the claimant to the higher rate. However, an appeal in April resulted in a second tribunal agreeing that a mistake had been made and ordering a recalculation.
When the DWP failed to implement the order, the claimant involved their Member of Parliament. This intervention revealed the existence of operational guidance that explicitly prevents staff from overriding the system manually. The department stated that the defect affects an “extremely small number of people” and is working to ensure customers do not face similar issues.
The DWP has assured the claimant that they will not be required to refund the overpayments. Despite this assurance, the claimant remains concerned about the broader implications. If a person subject to immigration control is deemed to have received public funds to which they are not entitled, the Home Office has the power to curtail their leave to remain.
Government Response and Scope
Attempts to determine the full scale of the error have been met with resistance. A freedom of information request asking for the total number of affected claimants and the total sum of erroneous payments was rejected. The DWP claimed that collating the information would be too expensive.
The department later stated it is aware of the issue and is working to correct the specific case in question. However, the refusal to provide data on the wider impact has left many wondering how many other families are in a similar position. The combination of a known technical failure and strict operational guidance has created a situation where the government is aware of the error but unable to fix it through standard procedures.
Source: The Guardian

