A senior surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has called for a criminal investigation into the hospital after it emerged that at least 19 patients died from avoidable complications during surgery. Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant at the facility, stated that he had repeatedly raised alarms about the safety of liver and pancreatic procedures since 2021, believing that dozens of patients may have died unnecessarily.
Dr Habib is urging Police Scotland to launch an inquiry into corporate homicide at the site. He alleges that senior officials at NHS Grampian, the health board responsible for the hospital, failed to act swiftly enough on his warnings. His solicitor, Aamer Anwar, published an expert report on Thursday that confirmed Dr Habib’s allegations. The report identified 19 deaths caused by serious adverse events between 2015 and 2021.
Expert Review Reveals High Mortality Rates
The findings were discussed at the Scottish Parliament on Thursday. John Swinney, the first minister, described the disclosures as being of the gravest concern. He emphasized that the health service has a legal duty to provide the best possible care and to investigate safety failures immediately. However, he rejected calls from Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra for a criminal investigation into the systemic failures at the board.
Dr Swinney defended the government’s response, noting that recent decisions to demand leadership changes and urgent reforms at NHS Grampian should yield the necessary improvements. He denied that the administration had ignored Dr Habib’s complaints in the past.
External experts who conducted a review in 2022 found that the death rate for liver and pancreatic surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary was extremely high. Between 2017 and 2020, the fatality rate reached as high as 18 percent. This figure stands in stark contrast to the national average for this specialty, which typically ranges between 2 and 3 percent depending on patient conditions.
Ongoing Concerns and Leadership Changes
Dr Habib, who continues to work at the hospital, noted that the surgical unit remained open even after the expert report was completed. He flagged four additional patient deaths that occurred during or after surgery following the publication of the review. In March 2026, another external expert concluded that the persistent high mortality in complex surgery was a red-flag indicator of systemic failure. Consequently, the liver and pancreatic surgery department was shut down.
Dr Habib stated that he had contacted the police, Scottish government ministers, and Scotland’s independent whistleblowing officer multiple times. He claimed he was often told the cases were time-barred or that his concerns were not being addressed adequately. His legal team argues that the health board is avoiding accountability by failing to be transparent about the damage caused.
Laura Skaife-Knight, the chief executive of NHS Grampian, acknowledged the serious allegations. She confirmed that a thorough investigation had already taken place, with some elements still ongoing. The health board stated that it would carefully consider any new evidence and continue to respond through appropriate clinical and legal processes. Skaife-Knight emphasized that patient safety remains the highest priority and that duty of candour processes are followed when reviews identify issues.
The allegations add to a series of medical and managerial crises at NHS Grampian. Paediatric surgery at Gray’s hospital has been shut down, and the board’s chairperson and medical director have been replaced. Angela Constance, the Scottish health secretary, recently told MSPs that there were extremely serious systemic problems with mismanagement and underperformance at the board. She warned that the health board could face special measures if current reforms are not introduced effectively.
A report by Healthcare Improvement Scotland last week found very serious shortcomings in the board’s leadership, including a lack of transparency in its accounts. While the report identified only one patient death due to a serious adverse event, Dr Habib and his solicitor argue that the evidence from the expert review suggests many more deaths were avoidable. They contend that this raises concerns about whether the full extent of the crisis is being covered up.
Dr Anwar called on the lord advocate, Ruth Charteris KC, to instruct her lawyers and Police Scotland to launch a criminal investigation. He also urged ministers to place NHS Grampian into special measures immediately. A Scottish government spokesperson recognized the courage shown by the whistleblower and stated that ministers had repeatedly raised the concerns with Healthcare Improvement Scotland and NHS Grampian. The government noted that any criminal investigation is a matter for Police Scotland.
Source: The Guardian

