Joker 2 Release Date and Initial Reactions
Scheduled for wide release in early October, Joker: Folie à Deux made its world premiere at the Venice International Film Festival. This highly anticipated film reunites Joaquin Phoenix with director Todd Phillips, while also introducing Lady Gaga as Harley Quinn. With a fresh perspective, The Joker 2 takes a musical direction, a move that has stirred significant debate among critics and fans.
Initial reviews have generated mixed reactions. As of now, the movie holds a Rotten Tomatoes score of 60%, just meeting the “fresh” threshold. Critics seem to be divided on whether the film lives up to the high bar set by its predecessor.

Polarizing Reviews and Rotten Tomatoes Joker 2 Score
Early reviews suggest that Joker 2 might struggle to replicate the cultural phenomenon of the original Joker. Several critics have pointed to its unique musical approach as a polarizing element. For instance, Hannah Strong of Little White Lies critiqued the film for not fully embracing its musical identity, questioning why Todd Phillips didn’t lean further into the musical aspects. Other reviews echoed this sentiment, with Eric Eisenberg of CinemaBlend calling it an “overindulgent musical” that fails to deliver the intensity of the first film.
Despite these critiques, some reviewers praised the film for its daring approach. John Nguyen of Nerd Reactor found the film’s musical sequences to be pivotal and praised the performances of Lady Gaga and Joaquin Phoenix. Empire critic John Nugent acknowledged that the film may not be for everyone but appreciated its “strange, tragic hopefulness.”
Joker 2 Review: A Hit or Miss?
While some critics have been impressed by Joker 2, others have found it lacking. Tim Grierson of Screen International criticized the film’s musical sequences, stating they “reside in an unsatisfying, indifferent middle ground.” He also noted that the chemistry between Lady Gaga and Joaquin Phoenix failed to ignite the on-screen dynamic one might expect from Joker and Harley Quinn.
Conversely, positive reviews have praised the film’s uniqueness. JoBlo hailed it as the “movie of the year,” and several reviewers have applauded Phoenix and Gaga for their committed performances. However, much of the praise appears to center on the performances, while critiques often target the film’s musical format.
Audience Rotten Tomatoes Score For Joker 2: Will It Rise or Fall?
As Joker 2 awaits its general release, there is still time for its Rotten Tomatoes score to fluctuate. With more reviews yet to come, the 60% rating may climb, especially if audiences respond positively to the film’s bold choices. The first Joker film similarly faced critical backlash upon its release but went on to enjoy immense success among general audiences, leading to its stellar audience score.
Ultimately, Joker: Folie à Deux has stirred mixed emotions, much like the original. Whether you love or hate it, the sequel is shaping up to be a cinematic event worth experiencing.
For now, all eyes are on the 60% Joker 2 Rotten Tomatoes score, but only time will tell if it can rise above or fall short of expectations.
Joker: Folie à Deux will be hitting theaters on October 4, 2024.