The Scottish government has launched an urgent independent review into hepatobiliary surgery at NHS Grampian following the leak of a document detailing 19 avoidable patient deaths. Health Secretary Angela Constance announced the inquiry after a whistleblower provided evidence that concerns about patient safety were not adequately addressed by the health board or previous government officials.
The leaked report, originally compiled in 2022, examined 31 deaths among patients who underwent liver, gallbladder, or bile duct surgery. It concluded that 19 of those deaths could have been prevented. Dr Mohammed Habib, a surgeon at the board, has claimed he raised these safety concerns with the Scottish government on four separate occasions and also contacted the police and the lord advocate.
Whistleblower Claims Ignored for Years
Dr Habib stated that two patients died after undergoing the wrong surgical procedures. He has called for a corporate homicide inquiry into the health board, arguing that systemic failures led to unnecessary loss of life. The document he released highlights a significant gap between the warnings he provided and the actions taken by NHS Grampian leadership.
Constance described the concerns raised by Dr Habib as deeply concerning and of the utmost seriousness. She confirmed that the review would assess how the board and the Scottish government handled these specific warnings. The inquiry aims to identify weaknesses in governance, missed opportunities for intervention, and gaps in accountability that allowed the issues to persist.
Humza Yousaf, who served as health secretary when the 2022 report was initially produced, stated that he supports full transparency. A spokesperson for Yousaf, who later became first minister before resigning in May 2024, said he would cooperate fully with the review and supported the release of minutes from that period. Yousaf emphasized that staff who raise patient safety concerns must be listened to and protected.

Immediate Support and Political Fallout
In response to the scandal, Constance appointed an external intervention support team comprising senior NHS leaders to oversee improvements at NHS Grampian. Healthcare Improvement Scotland has been tasked with completing an early review of the board within three months to assess progress. The government also pledged to take immediate steps to secure relevant files and records, noting that any issues involving potential criminality would be referred to authorities without waiting for the final report.
Patients and families affected by the surgery outcomes have been urged to contact the NHS Grampian helpline for advice and support. Derek Appleton, a patient who underwent liver surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, told BBC Scotland News that he believed mistakes were made during his procedure. Appleton reported losing 11 litres of blood and going into cardiac arrest, yet he said he was never given a proper explanation for what happened.
Political opponents have criticized the delay in action. Scottish Labour health spokeswoman Jackie Baillie said the review was welcome but stressed that grieving families deserve the full truth about who knew what and when. Scottish Liberal Democrat MSP Yi-pei Chou Turvey described the wait for answers as excruciating, calling for ministers to explain why they failed to intervene despite multiple warnings. Scottish Conservative health spokesman Miles Briggs warned that the review must not be used to shirk responsibility and must follow the evidence wherever it leads.
Constance is scheduled to make a statement in the Scottish Parliament on Tuesday, where she will outline the timetable for the review and announce the independent expert who will lead it. She acknowledged the courage it took for Dr Habib to come forward after years of seeking attention for his concerns.
Source: BBC

